There are about 4,000 restaurants on Long Island. Needless to say, you’ll have a lot to choose from!
Are you searching for the best restaurants Long Island has to offer?
We’ve got you covered whether you’re looking for upscale cuisine or hole-in-the-wall spots. From classic seafood boils to trendy poke bowls and authentic Mexican, here are the seven best restaurants on Long Island in New York:
1. The Halyard, Greenport
You can’t go wrong with the Halyard Greenport. This seafood-focused spot is beloved by locals and visitors alike for its fresh, locally-sourced fare. From the succulent lobster rolls to the crispy fried clams, there’s something for everyone to enjoy at the Halyard Greenport. And don’t forget to savor the stunning harbor views while you dine!
2. Jamesport Manor Inn, Jamesport
In Jamesport, NY, the Jamesport Manor Inn is a top pick for foodies looking for the best restaurants on Long Island.
The Inn’s exquisite dining room offers charming views of the Long Island Sound, and the menus focus on fresh, seasonal, and locally sourced ingredients.
Dishes are creative and elegantly presented, making Jamesport Manor Inn a perfect choice for a special night out.
The wine list is impressive, and the knowledgeable staff is happy to recommend the perfect bottle to pair with your meal.
Whether you’re looking for a romantic evening or a night out with friends, Jamesport Manor Inn is sure to please.
3. La Tavola, St. James
“La Tavola St James” is a hidden gem known for its outstanding food and service. The menu is constantly changing, but you can always find something delicious to eat. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff is friendly and helpful. This is the perfect place for a romantic dinner or a night out with friends.
4. The Bell & Anchor, Sag Harbor
In Suffolk County, on the east end of Long Island, The Bell & Anchor is a seafood-focused restaurant in Sag Harbor. It’s on the water, with an outdoor patio for dining in the summer. The menu changes seasonally but might include dishes such as scallops with ramp pesto, lobster rolls, or black bass with fiddlehead ferns. The wine list has predominantly American wines, and craft beers are available.
5. Old Homestead Steakhouse
Another great restaurant on Long Island is Old Homestead Steakhouse. This iconic spot has been serving up some of the best steak dishes for years, and it’s definitely worth a visit.
The menu features all of your favorite steakhouse classics, and the quality of the meat is second to none. The Old Homestead Steakhouse is known for its dry-aged beef and has been serving steaks since 1868. If you’re looking for a fantastic steak dinner, this is the place.
6. LaBella Pizza In Huntington
Many locals will say that part of finding the right neighborhood on Long Island to live in is finding one with a great Italian restaurant. One of the best Italian restaurants on Long Island is LaBella Pizza, located in Huntington. The pizza is amazing, and the atmosphere is perfect for a night out with friends or family, another great option for red sauce lovers.
7. The Montauk Lake Club
If you’re looking for a waterfront dining experience, you won’t want to miss the Montauk Lake Club. Located on the eastern end of Long Island, the Montauk Lake Club is an upscale restaurant that offers breathtaking views of the lake and stunning sunsets. The menu features fresh, local seafood and produce, and the wine list is impressive.
Whether you’re looking for a romantic dinner for two or a night out with friends, the Montauk Lake Club is sure to please.
Explore the Best Restaurants on Long Island
If you’re a foodie looking for the best restaurants on Long Island, then look no further than our list. From fine dining to casual eating, there’s something for everyone. So what are you waiting for? Get out there and start exploring!
If you’re looking for more restaurant recommendations for Long Island, check out our blog for more great content.