Cedar shake roofs have a certain magic about them. They’re a bit whimsical, rustic, and rough-round-the-edges. They give a home the kind of character that you just can’t achieve with synthetic materials. You’ll see cedar shake roofing everywhere from coastal properties to mountain lodges and high-end suburban developments.
Not only are they stunning to look at, they’re also sustainable. However, maintaining a cedar shake roof requires commitment, and it certainly isn’t for everyone. If you’re weighing the pros and cons, here’s a realistic look at what you’d gain and what you’d give up by choosing natural wood.
Pros of Cedar Shake Roof
First, let’s explore the positive aspects of installing a cedar shake roof on your property.
Aesthetics
Whether you’re a cedar shake fan or not, there’s one aspect you can’t argue with: it looks incredible. Each shake is unique, with its own grain and warmth of tone. Over the course of a cedar shake roof lifespan, it weathers into soft silvery grays that suit both traditional and contemporary architecture.
Insulation
Cedar is a natural insulator, so it can help keep your home cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. It also insulates sound, softening heavy rainfall and dulling the thuds of hail. You’ll notice the difference in comfort right away.
Eco-friendly
We all need to do our part to protect the planet, and cedar is a great option since it’s a renewable resource. If it’s harvested and treated responsibly, it’s one of the most environmentally friendly roofing materials out there, since it’s also biodegradable.
Long-term value
Cedar shake roofs are often seen as a premium feature in both modern and heritage-style homes. This could attract luxury buyers and boost your home’s resale appeal with those who appreciate quality craftsmanship.
Cons of Cedar Shake Roof
While there are plenty of benefits, cedar shake roofs come with some downsides as well.
Regular care
Cedar needs regular cleaning, professional inspections, and treatments to protect against mold, moisture, and insects. You need to be prepared for the time and cost investment this incurs.
Expense
As well as ongoing maintenance, cedar shake roofs tend to cost more upfront. Installation isn’t as fast as with some other roof types. The shakes themselves can be pricey, especially if they’re handcrafted, as traditional ones are. It’s definitely a long-term investment rather than a budget choice.
Climate restrictions
Cedar shake roofs aren’t ideal in fire-prone zones or coastal areas. In dry climates, the wood can dry out or crack without frequent treatments and coatings. Humid conditions make it easier for cedar to absorb moisture and grow moss or algae.
Changing look
The evolving appearance of cedar shake is one of its most distinct features, but not everyone loves it. If you’re drawn to the rich reddish tone of a new roof, but you’re not so keen on the mottled gray as it ages, perhaps you’re better suited to a synthetic, uniform material.
Endnote
If you appreciate traditional craftsmanship and don’t mind the extra upkeep that comes with it, a cedar shake roof could be right for you. They age beautifully, perform well, and bestow serious amounts of charm on your property. Overall, cedar shake is a material that rewards care and attention. If you maintain it well, you can enjoy a roof that looks alive, feels organic, and protects your family for decades to come.
